Argumentation
The ability to build a logical and convincing position: thesis, evidence, handling counterarguments and honest acknowledgment of the limits of one's argument.
Definition
BT360 v2.0.0The ability to build a logical and convincing position: thesis, evidence, handling counterarguments and honest acknowledgment of the limits of one's argument.
What is it made up of?
3 INDICATORS- 01Structure of thesis and evidence
- 02Working with counterarguments
- 03Honesty about the limits of the argument
Behavior levels 0–5
MANAGER'S GOAL - 4| Lv. | Label | Descriptor |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | Absent | Asserts without evidence; argues from 'that's how I feel'; meets a counterargument with aggression or repetition; does not distinguish opinion from fact. |
| 1 | Poorly developed | Offers one or two arguments, often irrelevant; does not hear the counterargument; confuses cause with example; under pressure either drops the position or digs in. |
| 2 | Underdeveloped | Builds understandable reasoning on a familiar topic; takes counterarguments into account only partly; does not separate strong from weak arguments; rarely admits limits. |
| 3 | Normally developed | States a thesis and backs it with facts; distinguishes types of arguments; answers counterarguments on the merits; admits where the evidence is insufficient. |
| 4 | Highly developed leader's goal | Builds multi-level argumentation; finds the weak points of their own position in advance; uses the opponent's steelman; changes position when better data appears; persuades without pressure. |
| 5 | Overdeveloped | Argumentation becomes winning at any cost: the person overwhelms the other side, picks arguments after the answer is known, ignores context; the conversation ends with their being right and everyone else silent. |
How is it measured?
coating BSJT - BT360 situational test: provides a hypothesis about judgments in work situations and does not replace observation, 360 and interviews.
REI shows a tendency to rational analysis, communicative competence is a general self-report. The quality of the argument is assessed only in the observable defense of the position.
Development Actions
5 CATEGORIESREI and a live defence of a position assessed on structure, handling of counterarguments and honesty.
Training 'Argumentation and the steelman': thesis, evidence, counterargument, limits.
Before every significant discussion, prepare three arguments and one strong counterargument against yourself.
Ask the opponent to rate whether their argument was heard; review where you pushed.
Introduce the rule 'state the opponent's best argument before you answer'.