Critical thinking
The ability to test assumptions, distinguish fact from interpretation, notice cognitive biases and change one's mind when stronger arguments appear.
Definition
BT360 v2.0.0The ability to test assumptions, distinguish fact from interpretation, notice cognitive biases and change one's mind when stronger arguments appear.
What is it made up of?
3 INDICATORS- 01Testing assumptions and sources
- 02Distinguishing fact, opinion and interpretation
- 03Willingness to change a conclusion with new data
Behavior levels 0–5
MANAGER'S GOAL - 4| Lv. | Label | Descriptor |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | Absent | Takes any statement on trust if it is convenient; does not distinguish fact from opinion; argues with the person rather than the argument; clings to the previous conclusion when new data appears. |
| 1 | Poorly developed | Notices obvious contradictions but does not check the source; argues from authority; errs on basic assumptions; a change of mind feels like defeat. |
| 2 | Underdeveloped | Checks facts when there is time; under pressure accepts the convenient version; can name a bias but does not always apply it to themselves; changes their mind with difficulty. |
| 3 | Normally developed | Checks sources and assumptions; separates observation from interpretation; asks 'how do we know this' and 'what could be different'; changes the conclusion when the arguments are strong. |
| 4 | Highly developed leader's goal | Quickly finds the weak link in reasoning, including their own; distinguishes levels of confidence; actively seeks disconfirming data; changes position publicly without losing face; builds a culture of checking assumptions. |
| 5 | Overdeveloped | Critique becomes a stance: every argument is taken apart, nothing is accepted; doubts everything and blocks decisions; intellectual superiority destroys trust and paralyzes the team. |
How is it measured?
coating BThe short version InQ shows preferred styles, REI shows a tendency towards rational analysis. Neither measures the quality of assumption testing; The main method is a case with a trap.
Development Actions
5 CATEGORIESREI and MDMQ (vigilance); a case with a deliberately false assumption, assessing whether the person caught it.
Course 'Critical Thinking and Working with Assumptions': sources, biases, argumentation, steelmanning.
Before every significant decision, write down three assumptions and how to test them; once a month review a decision that turned out to be wrong.
Assign a 'devil's advocate' in key discussions and review which objections were ignored.
Adopt a team rule 'data first, opinion second' for decisions with a high cost of error.