THK-07 Core

Decision making

The ability to choose among alternatives on time, considering the cost of error, available data and consequences, and to own the choice. Decision maturity is measured by the quality of the process, not by speed.

coating AThinking and decisions3 indicators6 levels
Target level · manager4 out of 4
ClusterThinking, analysis and decisions

Definition

BT360 v2.0.0

The ability to choose among alternatives on time, considering the cost of error, available data and consequences, and to own the choice. Decision maturity is measured by the quality of the process, not by speed.

What is it made up of?

3 INDICATORS
  • 01Building alternatives and selection criteria
  • 02Choosing on time with the cost of error in mind
  • 03Owning the consequences

Behavior levels 0–5

MANAGER'S GOAL - 4
Lv.LabelDescriptor
0AbsentDoes not make decisions: waits for others to choose; or chooses impulsively without criteria; shifts responsibility for the consequences; repeats the same mistakes.
1Poorly developedChooses by first impression; does not collect alternatives; gets stuck on trivia and rushes the important; under pressure hands the choice to the manager.
2UnderdevelopedUses simple criteria; collects 2–3 alternatives; decides confidently in familiar situations and postpones in complex ones; assesses the consequences only partially.
3Normally developedFormulates criteria and collects alternatives; considers the cost of error and reversibility; decides on time; explains the logic and takes responsibility for the consequences.
4Highly developed leader's goalMakes complex decisions on incomplete data; distinguishes reversible from irreversible; uses fast test cycles; involves the right people without giving away responsibility; learns from the outcome.
5OverdevelopedDecisions are made too fast and alone; speed is valued above quality; alternatives are not considered; cannot tolerate a pause and does not hear objections; the cost of errors grows.

Development Actions

5 CATEGORIES
Diagnostics

GDMS, MDMQ and DMC; review of three real decisions with an assessment of the process and the consequences.

Training

Course 'Decision Making': criteria, alternatives, cost of error, reversibility, biases, post-mortem.

Practice

Keep a decision journal: context — alternatives — criteria — choice — expectation — fact; do a post-mortem once a month.

Feedback

Discuss with a mentor two decisions where you got stuck and two where you rushed; derive personal rules.

Wednesday

Introduce a decision-rights matrix in the team and the rule of recording criteria before discussing the options.

What to watch

INTERVIEW AND BEHAVIOR
Question 1Tell us about a difficult decision you made. How did you collect alternatives and criteria?
Question 2What decision do you regret? What would you do differently about the process rather than the outcome?
ObservationIn the case: the structure of choice, readiness for irreversibility, speed, responsibility for the outcome.
Sign of hypertrophySpeed instead of quality and individuality.